I Don’t Care About Facts… My Mind Is Made Up!

“The greatest deception men suffer is from their own opinions.”

~Leonardo da Vinci

Although he is best known as a master artist, da Vinci (1452 – 1519) is renowned as one of the greatest creative geniuses in history. He is regarded as the prime example of the “Universal Genius” or  “Renaissance Man”, because his areas of interest included just about every conceivable field of study.

I smiled when reading these words by Leonardo for the first time, because it reminded me of another, rather vulgar, simile used to illuminate the meaning of the term opinion. In a free, democratic society one is entitled to express his/her opinion at will – guaranteed by the right of freedom of speech. As a matter of fact, I am exercising this right in the composition of this reflection.

The teacher in me insists that I begin by defining my terms. Plato, the great philosopher of ancient Greece, explained that opinion or common belief is quite subjective and somewhat uncertain. Opinions extend from our preferences or tastes to our views about many subjects of interest to most people. These include views held by learned people who have acquired expertise in a particular subject. So, while some opinions are quite indefensible, others are grounded by fact and logic.

In our free society, we are clearly entitled to hold and express opinions about anything that interests us. But we are not entitled to have our opinions valued equally to anyone else’s views on a given topic. If I hold a point of view that can be defended with indisputable data and arrived at logically, then it merits respect. While my right to express that opinion must be respected, the opinion itself must be judged on its merits.

In this quote, Leonardo da Vinci warns us against self-deception because of the opinions we hold. Too often, people confuse their opinion with the truth. Just because I might think that women are better suited to hold leadership positions than men, does not make it so. Nor is the opposite point of view any more valid, because both are based upon blatant sexism. Gender has nothing to do with one’s ability to lead, as history is rife with examples of great leaders of both genders.

I see two dangers here. The first, is that if we arrive at an opinion and decide that it is the only correct view to have on the topic, then we deceive ourselves. Not only that, but in our dogged determination to convince others to agree with our truth, we perpetrate an attitude of closed-mindedness. This, in turn, closes off any meaningful debate so that differences of opinion become shouting matches that can turn violent. At best, we harm no one but ourselves by our stubborn rigidity; at worst the condition spreads like an intellectual plague throughout society.

The other danger is that we can, in our self-righteous zeal, determine that other, conflicting points of view are not valid and worthy of respect. Such a conclusion, in a democratic society, can result in the dictatorship of the majority where opposing views are suppressed. Such a closed society cannot grow and flourish because it is not open to change. This is not healthy for an individual or for society at large.

Because the United States is the leader of the free world, the Presidential election process underway currently is of great concern, not only to Americans, but to their friends and allies alike. Republican frontrunner, Donald Trump has come to dominate media attention throughout this campaign. His rhetoric of social division and condemnation of the status quo is accompanied by sneers and much fist waving at adoring crowds of followers. Although I find Mr. Trump personally repugnant, I fear his power more than the man himself.

Trump’s demeanor is confrontational, unyielding and blatantly disrespectful. He postures before the media as the quintessential bully, which seems to delight his supporters. We have seen several instances of protestors being confronted violently by those who support his candidacy for President. His message of social intolerance towards immigrants and non-WASP (White Anglo-Saxon Protestant) Americans resonates with people who feel disenfranchised economically and are eager to blame their troubles on easily identifiable scapegoats.

Donald Trump is not the first extremist to use the tactics of social division and economic scapegoating to win political office. Adolf Hitler and the Nazis used these and other, more ruthless tactics to gain control of Germany’s democratic government by 1933. Hitler was one of the greatest demagogues in history, who appealed to popular desires and prejudices to establish authoritarian rule and abolish freedom and individual rights.

Probably our greatest safeguard against this type of extremism is to heed well the words of Leonardo da Vinci. We need to be open to the ideas of others and defend their right to express them. It is also important realize that at no time does any particular person or group have exclusive ownership over wise choices for society. To be a healthy society that encourages growth, we need to free ourselves from deceptions emanating from our opinions. Thank you, Leonardo da Vinci!

Advertisements

Author: John Fioravanti

I'm a retired History teacher (35 years), husband, father of three, grandfather of three. My wife, Anne, and I became business partners in December, 2013, and launched our own publishing company, Fiora Books (http://fiorabooks.com), to publish my books. We have been married since 1973 and hope our joint business venture will be as successful as our marriage.

6 thoughts on “I Don’t Care About Facts… My Mind Is Made Up!”

  1. Freedom of speech does not give one the license to impose one’s believes on others. When that happens, as you right noted, it becomes dictatorship. Only the bullies think they can force themselves on others. Thank you John for sharing.

    Like

  2. John, while I was sitting here reading your inspirational post, I was thinking about the number of times I was seething at the GOP front runner, Donald Trump. Not only me, but the millions of other voters who elected our present charismatic president Barack Obama. You better believe, and I am predicting, that Trump will lose big in the general election because it is more of us than him and his ilk. The GOP field is constantly denigrating our president to the world and its making me sick to see it. You are absolutely correct when you say we must not think that our truth is the exact issue to believe and accept. That’s why we have a democracy in the USA. I am afraid we are allowing the minority to change the rules and ignore our constitutional amendments.

    I’m glad you brought this issue up because we are living it right now and you are correct, the world is watching. By the way I love your new young prime minister. He and our president hit it off at the State Dinner. Maybe its because he is young and idealistic but maybe not. He came from the Trudeau’s.

    Thank you for sharing this thought-provoking post.

    Like

    1. Thanks for writing this thoughtful commentary, Shirley. Personally, I am thrilled that Justin’s election win last October established Canada’s first dynasty in the Prime Minister’s role – following in the footsteps of his father, my political hero, Pierre Elliott Trudeau! I was so proud and pleased to see President Obama and PM Trudeau hit it off so well! Thanks for your kind remarks!

      Like

  3. From the sublime to the… rowdies! Great post John – the politics of ‘(s)he who shouts loudest’ is always a threat to be ignored for the sake of everyone’s freedoms.

    Like

I love comments & questions! Please share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s